National overview of methodologies and systems for validation of non-formal and informal learning in Denmark
By Prof. Erwin Seyfried (FHVR Berlin) and Manuel Souto Otero (ECOTEC Research and Consulting)/Manuel Souto's version 3.2.2006 with amendments by Annelise Hauch 10.2.2006
As such, validation of non-formal and informal learning plays an important role in Denmark's education policy agenda. The Adult Education Reform (2001) strengthened the emphasis on competence-based and lifelong learningoriented systems (s. Danish Ministry of Education, 2002). The reform aimed at an approach to validation that meets the needs of the individual and enterprises. There has been an increasing focus on learning and developing skills outside the formal education system in Denmark (s. ASEM (2), p. 32; Danish Government, 2002). Therefore, better linking of formal, non-formal and informal learning was a goal of the 2001 reform initiative. Validation of non-formal and informal learning as part of this process opens up increasingly flexible pathways between formal education and training and workplace and institutional learning (s. ASEM (2), p. 32).
The present and future initiatives of the Danish Ministry of Education are aiming at promoting a more coherent and systematic practice of recognizing non-formal and informal learning together with formal learning for crediting in education and training (mainstream system as well as provision for adults).
A policy paper on validation of 'real competences' as a follow-up to the 2002 Better Education Action Plan by the coalition government was introduced in Parliament in November 2004. The policy paper "Recognition of Prior Learning within the Education System" ("Anerkendelse af realkompetencer i uddannelserne") contains a set of principles for enhanced assessment and recognition of prior learning (i.e. formal, non-formal and informal), and plans for next steps:
Recognition of prior learning after competence assessment may result in the following:
In its parliamentary debate the policy paper met with general endorsement from all political parties. In 2005, all parts of the education and training sector, the social partners and the third sector were invited to take part in development initiatives and dialogue. The necessary legislative amendments are being and will continue to be prepared to implement the initiatives outlined in the paper. Development work has been initiated, including development of clarification (identification) and documentation schemes in working life as well as in the third sector (liberal adult education and civil society activities).
Section two relies importantly on the information contained in the paper and a presentation from Annelise Hauch (Danish Ministry of Education) to the OECD in January 2006.
A crucial issue, which the Danish Ministry of Education is currently examining is the need to look at the use of fiscal tools that can help regulate the prior learning assessment activity. Educational institutions, the Ministry argues, must have the proper financial incentives to recognise an applicant's prior learning including resulting reduction of study time on an individual basis. The 'taximeter principle' (funding per student activity) works as a negative incentive in this respect because it encourages the institution to offer the 'whole package'. Existing arrangements operate with funding per individual competence assessment or per personal study plan.
The challenge is how to strike a balance between financial incentives encouraging the institutions to recognise prior learning, including preparing shorter study plans where relevant, and avoiding over-encouragement ('speculation' on the part of the institutions and a negative effect on the quality).
On the whole, the Ministry will try to ensure that within the public budget available priority is awarded to those with the lowest level of education and training. Graduated user fees for competence assessment will be introduced, except for the low skilled when their objective is a personal study plan.
2. Existing initiatives
2.1 Public authorities
The Danish experiences with validation of non- and informal learning are based mainly on the adult vocational training and vocational education and training schools (s. Danish Ministry of Education, interview May 12, 2004; The Danish University of Education, interview June 21, 2004). Yet important developments have recently occurred in other areas.
This section of the chapter presents an updated overview of existing arrangements on recognition of prior learning in the following areas: General Upper Secondary education, Vocational Education and Training, tertiary education; General Adult Education at basic levels, Adult Vocational Training (CVT), the Basic Adult Education Scheme and Advanced Levels in the Adult Education System.
2.1.1 General Upper Secondary
Education: A more flexible credit transfer system
Within general upper secondary education, a new A Level reform in Denmark (taking effect from 2005) has introduced a credit transfer system for A Level students based on an assessment of the individual student's prior learning. The objective is to give the students the opportunity to get credit transfers for previously completed studies, stays abroad etc. and therefore be granted admission to subjects at a higher level or extra optional subjects or a reduced A Level course if the particular credit transfer is very substantial.
2.1.2. Initial VET: Individual competence assessment as
a general principle
Following the Better Education Action Plan the government has amended the Initial VET legislation, taking effect from 1 August 2003, introducing a general principle of individual competence assessments as a basis for preparation of the trainee's personal education plan. In order to manage the highly individualised VET programmes, all trainees have to have a personal education plan drawn up, both young and adult trainees. Together with a contact teacher (tutor) the trainees draw up a personal education plan describing all the objectives and how to attain them. The personal education plan is based on an assessment of the trainee's competences and outlines and individual pathway through the VET system. When the trainee starts practical training in an enterprise, the latter is also involved in defining overall objectives for the training in cooperation with the trainee.
Flexible pathways adapted to the trainee's actual ('real') competences may lead to a shorter education (exemptions), but may also lead to longer education pathways or additions in order to enable the trainee to benefit more.
The national trade committee for a particular VET programme has the authority to decide on exemption from programme requirements that exceeds four weeks (exemptions of up to weeks being within the authority of the college). The social partners are equally represented in the bipartite trade committees.
In connection with 2004 amendments of legislation, similar provisions of individual assessment of competences now apply at the institutions of social and health education.
Since 1992, following a Parliament resolution, all ministerial orders on initial VET programmes regulated that in Adult VET, students at least 25 years of age who can document relevant non-formal learning may get credit as part of a VET programme. In general, these former special arrangements are now being replaced by the general principle of individual competence assessment of trainees in the initial VET system (however, for specific reasons, some VET programmes expressly indicate special pathways for adults with prior learning).
2.1.3 Mainstream Tertiary Education:
Within tertiary education, the individual educational institutions may as previously grant admission to students on the basis of individual assessments of these applicants' qualifications when the applicants have actual qualifications that are comparable to the general formal admission requirements (exemption from formal requirements).
In June 2004, the Government decided to change the restricted admissions system for tertiary education with effect from summer 2007. The quota system under restricted admission up to now has a number of weaknesses, as it has raised many false hopes about getting a quota II place through an often futile hunt for points. The objective of the new admissions system is, firstly, to encourage and assist young people to complete their studies faster and minimize the time between completing their A Levels and continuing their studies at tertiary level, and secondly, to strengthen the course-specific qualifications of the successful applicants in order to reduce the drop-out rate.
Quota I, which is based on the results from the qualifying examination, will with minor adjustments continue to be the absolute main admission route to the studies where admission is restricted.
Quota II has been changed. Quota II a applies to certain selected studies and provides a small group of applicants with a further chance of admission after a reduction in the quotient, including adjustment for any relevant coursespecific skills enhancement. With respect to the other subgroup, quota II b, the educational institutions are still able to admit students following individual assessments and entrance examinations or similar. There must be room for exemptions, i.e. for applicants who do not meet the general admission requirements in the form of A levels etc. but who have actual qualifications that following a competence assessment are considered comparable with A Levels and who also meet specific admission requirements, if any, for the particular course in question. Thus, quota II b provides opportunities for prior learning assessment of the individual applicants.
In short, the new system clearly attaches importance to qualifications for studying but also provides opportunities for prior learning assessment with the aid of examinations, interviews, and other means.
2.1.4. General Adult
On the whole, practice in Preparatory Adult Education (literacy and numeracy courses) already lives up to the principles of the Government policy paper on recognition of prior learning, especially through individual competence assessment for placement at suitable level and personalised study plan. The same may be said for General Adult Education at lower secondary level, although development and enhancement is called for.
2.1.5. Vocationally oriented adult education and training
184.108.40.206. Adult Vocational Training ('AMU', CVT):
Individual Competence Assessment and individual Training Plan
Since 1997 the Continuing Vocational Training (CVT) centres and the technical and commercial Vocational Education and Training (VET) colleges have been offering individual competence assessment (ICA) for identification of competences and referral to courses within the adult vocational training programmes (AMU). The goal is twofold: Firstly, to establish individual training plans that identify the individual's prior formal and non-formal learning; secondly, to offer individual training in accordance with (since 2004) the participant's job competence profile as reference point, and drawing up an individual training plan referring to the adult vocational training courses and VET single subjects listed in a common competence description that match the participant's job/competence profile.
The target group is employed workers of all skill levels. An individual may use the scheme for further personal or career development or, more typically, enterprises may use it as part of a Human Resources Development plan. The Public Employment Service may buy adult vocational training courses according to the identified needs of unemployed workers.
In the Adult Vocational Training scheme, ICA may be said to fall
into the category of formative assessment approaches, in which the
validation process helps the student to fill in the knowledge and
skills gaps on the way to meeting a job competence profile. The
purpose of the assessment is to assess prior learning of the
student and linking it to institutional learning which results in a
personalised study and training period at the adult vocational
training institution. However, especially since the 2004 amendment
of the Adult Vocational Training concept, which introduced joint
competence descriptions for adult vocational training courses and
VET single subjects, the ICA in relation to Adult Vocational
Training may result in recognition of prior learning, which gives a
right to credit transfer into initial VET, and therefore may be
said to be summative in this respect.
At the individual level, the ICA starting point is the individual's personal ideas and aspirations in job and education. At the enterprise level, the competence analysis focuses on the qualification needs of the company.
During the ICA the participant's prior learning is assessed by different methods (s. Danish Ministry of Education, 2002):
The training plan based on the assessment of the student's prior learning consists of technical, general and personal areas of learning needs.
The vocational training committees according to the legislation on Adult Vocational Training, in which the social partners are equally represented, do not play any part in individual competence assessment.
220.127.116.11. Basic Adult Education Scheme: Individual
competence assessment, Recognition of prior learning and individual
The Adult Education Reform (2001) introduced the Basic Adult Education Scheme ('GVU'). This scheme aims at introducing a new, more coherent and flexible way for low skilled adults to have their formal, non-formal and informal learning assessed and recognised with a view to acquiring formal VET qualifications while keeping their work.
The VET college offers a one-stop individual competence assessment and recognition of the student's prior learning. This forms the starting point for an individual study and training plan, which allows for part-time study in a single subject structure qualifying for a VET diploma, without the practical training part and therefore without an apprenticeship contract with an enterprise. The target group are part-time students who want to combine the study with continued employment (s. Danish Ministry of Education 2002). The admission criteria are threefold: 25 years of age, minimum two years of relevant work experience, and qualifications corresponding to compulsory school exit level in relevant subjects.
The Basic Adult Education Scheme is a summative approach to validation of non-formal and informal learning. It enables the student to close the knowledge gaps on the way to mastery (diploma identical to a VET diploma).
The reference points for the individual competence assessment (ICA) are the targets of the corresponding VET programme. These targets are indicated either in an annexe to the regulation of each VET programme or in attached guidelines. The assessment is part of the formal VET systems. ICA includes the two years of relevant work experience, which are admission requirements for the desired education programme, and should contribute towards exemption for the practical training part. For ICA methods, see above under Adult Vocational Training.
The personal study plan drawn up by one college on the basis of individual competence assessment is binding for other colleges that provide the same programme
In contrast to initial VET, the national trade committees in which the social partners are equally represented do not take part in the individual assessment and recognition of practical competences in a Basic Adult Education programme. The colleges inform the relevant trade committee on the individual study and training plans that it has drawn up for participants. The trade committee has the right to advise the school on future practice.
Individual Competence Assessment (ICA) in the Basic Adult Education programme and ICA in the CVT programme (see above) are to be merged into a joint concept.
18.104.22.168. Advanced levels of the Adult Education System:
Work experience as part of admission requirements, study in
interplay with work experience
The Adult Education System as part of the Adult Education Reform (2001) also introduced a new framework for further education at tertiary level.
The reform of the Adult Education System aims at better connecting formal education and non-formal learning at work. This promotes the goal of further education at advanced levels to develop progression in professional competence rather than the progression in study competence, which is dominant in the mainstream higher education programmes (s. Danish Ministry of Education, 2002).
The Adult Education Reform (2001) introduced relevant work experience as part of the entrance requirements for the Adult Education System. It is not recognized as part of the education programme though. However, the (shorter) duration and the organization of the content and teaching methods of the continued education programmes is to a high degree based on the life and work experience of the adults. Especially in connection with the final project there is interplay between theory and the adult's prior non-formal and informal learning acquired through work and life experience. In accordance with the Act on Open Education (which governs provision and financing of vocationally oriented adult education and training), the target group of the study programme are individuals that are still attending to their daily work.
The admission criteria for this programme are twofold: Relevant educational background and two years of relevant work experience are required. The educational institution assesses the relevance of the work experience in two dimensions: Firstly, relevant to the previous educational background and relevant to the desired further education programme.
In the context of implementation of the 2004 Government Policy Paper on Recognition of Prior Learning in the Education system, the following legal amendments are foreseen for the advanced levels of the Adult Education System to bring it in harmony with the principles of the paper:
2.2 Regional initiatives
Two projects have been initiated on the regional level: Firstly, a consortium of vocational schools in the Aarhus area together with the Danish Institute for Educational Training of Vocational Teachers are working on validation of prior learning. Secondly, an adult education and training centre on the island of Funen (Fyn) is a good practice example for accreditation of prior learning and innovative ways of meeting the needs of people who have little or bad experiences with schooling. Neither documentation nor interview partner have been available for detailed information on these projects so far.
2.3 Industry initiatives
The largest Danish Telecom company TDC assigned a private company, Ordkløveriet, to develop basic training for their dyslectic employees. Ordkløveriet introduced validation of informal learning in their 11-day basic training courses. In the first two days of the course, an elaborate testing system was used to find out about the status of the participants competences in reading and writing. The training facility had developed its own testing system which has been approved by the National Education Board in Denmark. The system consists of various tasks of reading and writing developed by Ordkløveriet, complemented by testing tools from outside specialists and individual 30 min interviews to find out about the learning needs and preferences of each participant.
The method falls into the category of formative validation approaches. It aims at customising the following nine-day courses on the basis of the recognized non-formal and informal learning results of the first two days of the course. At the end of the basic training the participants are tested via a questionnaire on their achievements during the course. So far two trial and three follow up courses with 15 participants each have taken place between November 2001 and spring 2003. More courses for TDS and for other companies in Denmark are planned.
It is important to mention that, in the context of the implementation of the Government Policy Paper on Recognition of Prior Learning in the Education System, the individual should have a responsibility for contributing to the documentation of his or her competences. Thus, methods and tools that the individual may use to describe and document his or her prior learning are of great importance for the assessment and recognition vis-à-vis the education system. It may also benefit the individual on the labour market, e.g. in connection with job seeking, or in his or her present job, just as it may support competence development in the enterprise.
There are already a variety of tools developed by companies, organisations related to the labour market and others, as well as a number of tools for job seeking. But clarification (identification) and documentation tools in the form of a portfolio in order to ensure the best possible interaction between people's work and leisure pursuits and the competence assessment vis-à-vis the education system need to be developed further.
The Ministry of Education is presently developing such tools in cooperation with on the one hand, the social partners and on the other hand, stakeholders in the 'third sector' (liberal adult education organisations and voluntary organisations etc.). These development projects should be completed by autumn 2006.
Also, access to clear information and guidance is seen as essential for both individuals and companies.
2.4 Third sector initiatives
There is little information in English on recognition of prior learning initiatives in the third sector available, although there are a number of interesting initiatives in place in relation to validation of non-formal and informal learning in the third sector in Denmark.
The day high school sector has done a project with developing the portfolio method together with the Danish Institute for Educational Training of Vocational Teachers. However, no documentation in English or interview partners have been available for further information. It is documented in Danish on http://www.daghojskoler.dk/ (link: portfolio & realkompetence).
New projects in the third sector are being developed. Seminars with scientific consultants have already taken place. Among the NGOs who have initiated development projects are: NetOp (Netværk for Oplysning) in cooperation with LOF (Liberalt Oplysnings Forbund), both adult education associations, and DUF (Dansk Ungdoms Fællesråd), which is the Danish Youth Council. Information in English on these particular projects can be found on the website of the Nordic Network for Adult Learning: www.nordvux.net/object/5982/validationobject.htm, andwww.nordvux.net/object/5981/validationobject.htm, respectively.
The "Danish Adult Education Association", which is a non-profit
umbrella association for the liberal adult education
associations and other associations within the
"Folkeoplysning", has also had, for some years now, a
"Realkompetenceforum": This is a forum for input, mutual learning and coordinating ongoing work in its member organisations. The Board of the Forum makes, and is responsible for, all political decisions on "Realkompetence" (Prior Learning including Non-formal and Informal) in liberal adult education. Links to ongoing projects are to be found on
/aktiviteter/realkompetencer/rkprojekterimedlemsorg. An English description of the Forum itself can be seen on http://www.nordvux.net/object/5983/validationobject.htm.
The Danish Government is taking the validation system further by going beyond recognizing formal and non-formal learning within the framework of the Adult Education System. A change of perspective towards the needs of the individual and enterprises is under way. National education policy also aims at a more coherent and systematic practice of validation of informal and non-formal learning.
There are some initiatives in the private and third sector. However, they are in the developing stage so that little information is available at this point. It is too early to assess the efficiency and effectiveness of the various Danish validation initiatives since there is too little information on the results and no evaluations available at this point.
Denmark does not have a tradition of evaluation. It is more - as one employee of the Danish Ministry of Education has put it "a tradition of trust". In the context of the unexpectedly negative Pisa study results, the topic of evaluation is gaining more and more importance which might also cover the validation initiatives on non-formal and informal learning.
Better Education. Action Plan, June 2002
ASEM Lifelong Learning Initiative:
Thematic Report 2: Integrated Approaches in Lifelong Learning and Recognition of Prior Learning. Working Group 2, September 2002
Danish Ministry of Education, Ministry of Science,
Technology and Innovation, Ministry of Culture, Ministry of
Economic and Business Affairs:
Recognition of Prior Learning within the education system. Danish Government policy paper presented to the Parliament, November 2004
Phone and email interviews:
Aalborg University, Centre for Interdisciplinary Study of Learning, April 26, 2004.
Aarhus Technical College, July 6, 2004.
Confederation of Danish Industries, May 3, 2004.
Danish Council for Adult Education, April 28, 2004.
Danish Federation of Trade Unions, April 30, 2004.
Danish Industries April 23, 2004.
Danish Ministry of Education, May 12, 2004.
Danish Ministry of Education June 24, 2004.
Danish University of Education, April 28 & 30, May 3 and June 21, 2004.
Ordkloeveriet, July 7, 2004.
Roskilde University, Department of Educational Research, April 27, 2004.
VUC FYN Glamsbjerg, Adult Education and Training Centre, August 6, 2004.
Workers' Education Association, April 30, 2004.